Ricoh’s Fairyland Problem: When Growth Isn’t Progress

Inspired by Ray Staszak’s “End of the Day with Ray”

Ricoh’s digital services playbook looks strong on the surface, but weak margins, unclear financials, and questionable strategic returns paint a more sobering picture. Correction may only come through outside pressure and internal reckoning.

I watched Ray's recent breakdown of Ricoh’s FY2024 financials and couldn’t stop thinking about one image: Ricoh’s “Inkjet Fairyland” booth at a convention. That phrase stuck with him, and it stuck with me too. Because it’s not just about trade show kitsch. It’s the perfect metaphor for a company trying to sparkle its way through serious operational issues.

Ray’s main critique was simple. Ricoh is making more money than ever from services, but profit margins keep shrinking. That’s not digital transformation. That’s a slow leak in a boat that just got a fresh coat of paint.

The more you dig into the numbers and industry reaction, the more it becomes clear. Ricoh’s pivot to digital services has a logic problem. Growth in top-line revenue does not mean operational success. What matters is how much of that growth you can actually keep.

The Illusion of Progress

According to Ricoh’s own investor materials, FY2024 revenue rose 7.6 percent to ¥2.53 trillion (around \$16.3 billion USD) thanks to expansion in digital services, recurring revenue, and production printing. But operating profit as a percentage of revenue declined again, dropping to 2.5 percent from 2.6 percent the year prior. That margin includes a one-time gain of ¥9 billion from an arbitration settlement. Without that, the margin would have been even lower.

This is not a one-off anomaly. This has been a consistent pattern across multiple fiscal years. The company’s earnings per share and return on equity are underwhelming. They’ve grown recurring revenue, yes, but that recurring revenue doesn’t seem to be doing any heavy lifting where it counts.

In Ricoh’s own words from their IR release: “Profitability remains challenged in certain regions due to structural changes and ongoing investments in service capabilities.” That’s corporate speak for spending a lot to build something that isn’t paying off yet.

A Costly Transformation

Ricoh’s digital services segment now accounts for more than half of total sales. This includes workplace solutions, IT infrastructure, application services, and managed services. On the surface, it’s exactly what every copier company says they want to be. Beneath the surface, the numbers tell a different story.

The Americas region, where much of this digital transformation is happening, posted an operating profit margin of just 1.1 percent in Q1 FY2024. That's a serious drop from 1.9 percent the year before. And this is the region that’s supposed to be leading the charge into IT services.

As The Recycler points out, Ricoh’s core office printing business continues to shrink, despite modest growth in production and commercial print. In that same report, analysts noted that Ricoh had to rely on favorable foreign exchange rates and non-operating income to hit its profit goals.

“Ricoh’s profitability has long lagged behind its peers,” said analyst Hiroshi Naya of Ichiyoshi Research Institute in Tokyo. “They’ve been trying to fix that for years with limited success.”

The Drupa Distraction

One of Ricoh’s bright spots, at least in terms of PR, was their return to Drupa 2024, the global print exhibition. Koji Miyao, President of Ricoh Graphic Communications, called it a “huge success” and said the company “signed many deals for groundbreaking inkjet and software platforms.”

But look at the numbers. Ricoh’s Graphics Communications division posted ¥2 billion in revenue, with a ¥188 million gain in commercial printing. That’s barely a 10 percent increase over last year and no better than growth in years without Drupa.

If Drupa is supposed to be a catalyst, the post-show financials don’t reflect it. This raises a hard question. Was the investment in Drupa really worth it, or was it just another illusion of progress?

No Clarity, No Confidence

Another issue is Ricoh’s financials. They are dense and opaque. Ray was right to ask about the ¥3 billion in “eliminations” listed in their segment breakdowns. That is not a small adjustment. Without clear detail on which parts of the business are dragging down margin, how can stakeholders trust the transformation story?

Ricoh created a manufacturing joint venture called Etra with Toshiba Tec and Oki. It was supposed to offload hardware complexity and allow Ricoh to focus on services. But Etra doesn’t appear as a separate line item, and there is little clarity on how it contributes to or subtracts from overall financial performance.

This lack of transparency undermines the entire services-led narrative. If services are really the future, why not show how they perform on their own?

Recurring Revenue, Unremarkable Results

Ricoh says 43 percent of its office services revenue is now recurring. Sounds impressive until you run the math.

Ricoh reports 1.4 million customers, and 36 percent of them (about 504,000) use office services. Recurring revenue in this segment is ¥348 billion, or about \$2.25 billion USD annually. Divide that by customer count and you get around \$4,400 per year, or \$366 per month per customer.

That’s not terrible, but for IT services? It’s lean.

You can’t run a global, high-touch IT services business on \$366 a month per client unless you’ve industrialized the process. Ricoh hasn’t. These numbers suggest low pricing, weak value capture, or bloated delivery costs. Probably a mix of all three.

Industry Context and Private Equity Pressure

Ricoh isn’t the only one facing these headwinds. HP, Xerox, and Canon are all wrestling with declining print volumes and rising cost pressures. But Ricoh’s trajectory seems uniquely stuck.

It’s worth noting that IF Capital now owns nearly 23 percent of Ricoh. IF is not a passive investor. They’ve already pushed change at Konica Minolta and are vocal about underperforming conglomerates. Private equity pressure may be Ricoh’s next real inflection point.

Meanwhile, the company continues to invest in edge services, print heads, and software layers, hoping these bets will pay off. But the basic math hasn’t changed. The cost to deliver is still outpacing profit margin.

Final Word

Here’s the personal part. I don’t think Ricoh is failing. I think Ricoh is stalling.

There’s a difference. Failing means the core is broken. Stalling means the pilot is trying to climb without enough airspeed. Ricoh wants to become a services company, but they are still tethered to a hardware heritage and a pricing model that was never built for IT.

They need to separate out real profitability from top-line vanity, expose the weak spots, and cut loose anything that can’t earn its weight. Investors will respect that. Dealers will trust that. Employees will rally around that.

But if they keep flying into the clouds without altitude, betting on slogans and slogans alone, they may find themselves back on the ground sooner than expected.

- Celeste Dame 🚀🧠
Sales whisperer, margin guardian, myth buster.

"I blend the grit of real-world selling with the brains of every methodology that ever worked—so you can close smarter, faster, and without losing your soul.

This isn’t inspiration. It’s activation."

---

🔗 Sources and Links

1. Ricoh FY2024 Financial Results
   Ricoh’s official financial report outlining FY2024 performance, including revenue, profit margins, and recurring revenue breakdowns.
   📎 https://www.ricoh.com/-/Media/Ricoh/Sites/com/IR/data/pre/pdf/r05q4_4.pdf

2. MarketScreener: Ricoh Consolidated Results FY2024
   Overview and financial context of Ricoh’s full-year results as presented to investors.
   📎 https://www.marketscreener.com/quote/stock/RICOH-COMPANY-LTD-6491237/news/Ricoh-FY2024-Financial-Announcement-May-14-2025-Consolidated-Results-49942574/

3. The Recycler: Ricoh Q1 Operating Profit Falls
   Article analyzing Ricoh’s Americas-region profit margins and structural challenges in services.
   📎 https://therecycler.com/posts/ricoh-sees-q1-sales-surge-profit-falls/

4. The Recycler: Ricoh Profits Rise Despite Headwinds
   Broad coverage of Ricoh’s year-end performance and outlook on future digital initiatives.
   📎 https://therecycler.com/posts/ricoh-profits-rise-despite-headwinds/

5. Ricoh at drupa 2024: Official Press Release
   Commentary from Ricoh leadership about drupa 2024 and its strategic outcomes.
   📎 https://www.ricoh-americalatina.com/en/newsroom/drupa-2024-surpassed-expectations-ricoh

6. Nikkei Asia: Ricoh's IT Push Under Scrutiny
   Analysis of Ricoh’s long-standing struggle to achieve profitability through IT and services.
   📎 https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Business-Spotlight/Ricoh-struggles-to-turn-IT-services-push-into-profit

---